Start with the complete size label
The 12 W title gives both nominal length and a wide category. The related Brown 11 leaves width unstated, and Brown 10.5 W is shorter. Those are separate purchase paths, not a recommendation to downsize or upsize within a wide family. If you need 12 in another width, locate that actual option rather than interpreting W as a universal improvement.
What the work-hiker specification supports
The official Keele Ridge page documents a steel toe and waterproof membrane in the leather-and-mesh upper. Its outsole is also described by the maker for slip resistance. Use the exact model evidence when assessing the route; waterproof and slip-resistant describe different properties, neither of which guarantees safety on every wet surface.
Compare a different construction only for a reason
Pit Boss Black 12 is a same-number boot comparison, but the listing does not state W and its ordinary family does not provide the Keele Ridge waterproof claim. If water exposure is the reason for choosing Keele Ridge, that difference matters more than brand continuity. If the issue is simply wanting a conventional work-boot upper, compare both shapes in the correct width.
Avoid using the maker’s sample-weight figure to predict the weight of size 12 W. Measurements tied to another size cannot settle which boot feels less cumbersome to you. Evaluate the whole pair and the coverage needed for your shift before treating a number from a product sheet as a ranking.