Why the separate Wide listing matters
Do not treat the two brown 10.5 offers as two distinct Pit Boss recommendations. They describe the same named family, with one title explicitly marking W. Check the width field on this offer before comparing prices; a lower price for a different width does not establish better value for the size you need.
What the ordinary Pit Boss is built around
The manufacturer presents Pit Boss as a nubuck, welted work boot with steel-toe and EH features. Its role differs from a low Intercept athletic shoe and from the waterproof Keele Ridge hiker. The decision among them is about format and construction, not moving up or down a single brand ranking.
Three useful 10.5 comparisons
Brown 10.5 W stays in the model while changing the stated width category. Wheat 10.5 gives an appearance route whose width also needs confirmation. Montauk Jet Black 10.5M introduces a cemented boot with a separately described underfoot setup. Decide which question you are investigating before comparing all three as if they differed only in styling.
If buying a replacement for a comfortable old Pit Boss, read the old label and use the current style information. The seller’s 2024 New wording does not by itself prove that the construction changed or stayed the same. A successful earlier pair is useful context, but the size and model supplied now still need to match the intended purchase.